Why is this marked so low in quality? Is it being marked down twice for being so easy? It has a (correct) rating of 'Difficilty: Easy' - that's fine. Yes, it has 4 straight groups with no clever tricks - is that the reason? But many hard/er grids, with no red herrings or crossovers, are not marked down in this way.

@ Curious - the setter initially sets the "difficulty" rating, and if wise will play the grid first and select 5*. Subsequent players assess the grid subjectively and will apply marks according to their own preferences. It is not always easy to differentiate between quality [i.e. construction, subject matter and style of puzzle] and personal enjoyment. Plus you will always get mean spirited trolls who like to mark grids down.

Good Observation, thanks. I have long thought that Puzzgrid should have an Enjoyment rating. Then I can mark down my enjoyment when there's sport, GoT, modern music etc., while still being happy to mark up the quality. 'Quality' covers different things to different people - that's maybe fine but your grid disappears from the main view if it's marked too low.